Cutting to the chase
If you do not have the time, or the inclination to read all of this article, the take home message is that we are asking you to consider becoming a patron in order to support our work.
You can see more details by going directly to our Patreon page.
PLEASE NOTE: Whenever you decide to support us, you will be charged for the full amount for that month. This is the way Patreon works, at least for the way we have joined the scheme.
So, if you join on the 15th of the month you will be charged the full amount for that month and then charged again on the 1st of the following month. We are unable to provide refunds, or accept part payment for the month you start supporting us. If you want to avoid this (although you can still access all the services offered in that month), we suggest that you join us at the start of a month, so that you get the full benefit for that month.
Background
Our Predatory Publishing Twitter account has been running for about two years. At the time of writing (15 Aug 2021) we have tweeted almost 21,000 times, ranging from EMAIL snippets from (probably) predatory journals, quotes from papers on predatory publishing, looking at common terms and highlighting journals/publishers that you might want to be wary of. We also use our Twitter account to promote our blog.
Our blog has been running for a similar amount of time and we have published around 50 articles. We would like to publish many more. We have lots of ideas but there are always time pressures and writing a blog posts takes quite a lot of time.
Our web site also supports our Twitter account and blog. We hope to develop the web site in the future to provide even more information.
Thank you
We have been delighted with the level of engagement we have received since we started this initiative.
We do track some metrics, albeit in an ad-hoc way, and it shows a general increase in interaction since we started our Twitter and blog.
We are indebted to all those that have supported us. Thank you.
Controversy
We recognize that we are tackling a very controversial area, where others before us have faced significant difficulties. This is the reason why we are, at the moment, remaining anonymous. Once we have the trust of the scientific community and some traction, we will be more transparent about who is behind this initiative. The target we have set ourselves in 10,000 Twitter followers but we do review this as a goal from time to time but, at the moment, this is still out goal. At the time of writing we are about 37% towards that goal.
"Can you help/advise me, or do you have a view?"
As we have gained more exposure and traction, we are often asked questions, or for our views, about journals and publishers. Although we respond, we often have to say that “we will add it to our ever growing list and will look at the journal/publisher when time allows.“
We do work through that list but it is a little ad-hoc and, to be honest, we choose the ones that we think are most interesting. It might be useful if we had a way of prioritizing the journals/publishers that we look at.
What are our plans?
With your help, we hope that we can develop this platform even further and do more than we are doing at the moment.
We have the following ideas that, with your help, we can progress.
- We are asking our patrons (see below) to request reviews of journals and publishers, this will not only make the content we produce more relevant but it will also provide a constant source of content that we hope our supporters will find interesting.
- As we develop our database of journals and publishers, we will compile a searchable database so that others can find out about the journals and publishers that we have investigated.
- The number of blog posts we can produce at the moment is limited, due to time limitations and other calls on our time. If our patrons are keen to write about predatory journals (see below), this would not only add additional blog posts but also give a different perspective, rather than just hearing our views all of the time.
- We are considering starting a YouTube channel that focuses on Predatory Publishing, but this is not possible at the moment. We are keeping this idea on the “nice to do” list, but we need more time and/or support to be able to progress.
- We would like to develop some short courses, so that scholars can have a more structured way to learn about predatory publishers, enabling them to avoid the pit falls. Like the YouTube channel, we require more time/support.
- We have reported on several occasions sting operations against predatory journals. We believe that this is an effective way to highlight those journals that are operating in a predatory way. We would like to have a sustained way of testing suspected journals, rather than just having one off examples. That said, we must be careful not to waste the time of legitimate journals.
- We would like to publish peer reviewed papers, in (obviously) non-predatory journals that record the results of our findings. If others are willing we would be delighted to co-author papers with like minded researchers.
- Given the data and knowledge that we have accumulated during our journey, we would like to publish a book that provides the history of predatory publishing, the state of predatory publish at the present time and what can be done about it going forward. This will be a longer term project but the first stage is to find potential co-authors and then develop a proposal for a suitable publisher.
- For those of you that follow our Twitter account, you will see that we tweet on various topics, such as EMAIL snippets from (probably) predatory journals and quotes from papers on predatory publishing. Some of you may have noticed that these tweets follow a similar layout and the reason that we are able to tweet so regularly is because we have automated much of the processes behind these tweets. It is not really to do with predatory publishing but we are thinking about sharing some of the ways we do this, perhaps on a different platform.
Our longer term plans include working with research institutes to provide a more bespoke service that we can offer at the moment.
Become a Patron
We would like to invite those that are interested in our work to become one of our patrons.
This will support us financially, which will enable us to do even more but, importantly, it will also enable us to be more targeted in areas that are of direct interest to the community.
We will also be able to engage with our patrons in a more meaningful way, especially those who, like us, want to eliminate predatory publishing and fake journals.
If you would like to be come a patron, please use this link and below we outline the various levels at which you can support us.
PLEASE NOTE: Whenever you decide to support us, you will be charged for the full amount for that month. This is the way Patreon works, at least for the way we have joined the scheme.
So, if you join on the 15th of the month you will be charged the full amount for that month and then charged again on the 1st of the following month. We are unable to provide refunds, or accept part payment for the month you start supporting us. If you want to avoid this (although you can still access all the services offered in that month), we suggest that you join us at the start of a month, so that you get the full benefit for that month.
1. Supporter
You will receive a monthly newsletter, that contains information that is either exclusive to our patrons or is provided ahead of time of being published on our other platforms. We will also use you as a sounding board for some of the ideas that we have.
2. Contributor
If you are interested in predatory/fake publishing and/or want to get some experience in writing/blogging, we would welcome one blog post a month from you. This will be published on our blog site (subject to editorial controls). We will help you to get the blog post as good as it can be so that it is a credit to you and us.
3. Journal Review
In each calendar month, you can request a review of a specific journal. We will provide some key data points (assuming the data is available). We will try to include:
- Whether the journal is recognized, or a member of, organizations such as ISSN, COPE, DOAJ and Scopus.
- Where the journal is located?
- How long it has been operating?
- How many articles have been published?
- Whether it is an open access journal.
- What are its Article Processing Charges (APCs)?
We will also provide our thoughts/comments as we carry out the investigation.
We will share this review on our blog site, so as to help others, but we will delay that post for at least a month so that you have the information before anybody else.
4. Publisher Review
In each calendar month, you can request a review of a specific publisher. We will provide key data points (assuming the data is available). We will try to include the following:
- How many journals the publisher has in their portfolio?
- Where the publisher is located?
- How long they have been operating?
- Whether they are indexed/members of organisations such as ISSN, COPE, DOAJ and Scopus?
- Whether they are only an open access publisher.
We will also provide our thoughts/comments as we carry out the investigation.
We are happy for you to request a review of a journal, rather than a publisher.
We will share this review on our blog site, in order to help others, but we will delay that post for at least a month so that you have the information before anybody else
7. Premium Supporter
This provides access to all of our other services. You will receive our newsletter, you can write a blog post each month and you can request both journal/publisher reviews, up to 10 in a calendar month, split across journal and publishers, whichever best meets your requirements.
As a premium supporter we will also provide you the other reviews that we have done at least a week before we publish them on our blog and/or web site, so that you get to see them before others (expect those that requested the review – they will get them first).
"I can't provide financial support at the moment"
We welcome any help that people can afford but if you cannot help at the present time (for whatever reason) no problem.
We hope that you will stay engaged and help us say spreading the word so that others can see what we are doing.